FLIPPING AWESOME TEACHING
  • My Flipping Blog
  • My Flipping Classroom
  • Articles/Media
  • Contact Info

You should flip your jigsaws!

3/21/2015

 
       I always liked the idea of jigsaw activities (good description here) -- to give students more ownership of their learning, to use class time differently, to invite some creativity, etc. The Expert Groups meet for 1 or 2 or 3 class periods to learn about a sub-topic and to prepare a short presentation about it. Then students break into the Home Groups to spend another class period or two teaching each other. However, in real life these activities can get messy very quickly: 
  • Some students read their material more slowly than others; other students rush through the individual work in their Expert Group. 
  • The volume level in the classroom distracts some students as they try to learn their topic for the first time.
  • What about students that were absent on the learning day? Jigsaws typically take 2 or 3 days to complete, so you get the problem of a student who missed the time in their Expert Group... what's he/she supposed to do now??

     If you flip it, then the Expert Groups can learn their material outside the classroom. Give them a couple nights to watch / listen to / read whatever you provide. Each student takes the time he/she needs, in a more appropriate location, regardless of their attendance at school. The small group peer pressure should help ensure that most or all come to class prepared. Let the Expert Groups meet briefly (less than a class period) to prepare and align their mini-presentations -- this is an important quality assurance step.  Then break student into the Home Groups and let the teaching begin!  
      
     The Civil War Trust has a fantastic set of informational videos about various aspects of the war.  Last June, I used these topics for the Expert Groups in a flipped jigsaw. I'm very glad that I assigned such short videos, because students re-watched them to improve their understanding.  We use Schoology, which allowed me to individually assign videos. On a regular website you could list all the video links on the same page, and then list the names of individuals or groups next to their assigned video.
Picture

Who needs printer ink & glitter glue?!

3/16/2015

 
Picture
   I love tonight's #flipclass focus: how can we address our students' mental health, while still doing our jobs.
    For one thing, I also give at least 2 (usually 3) nights for video-watching homework assignments -- no more than two per week. That helps to address potential technology access problems, but also it allows for my students' crazy over-scheduled lives. It's really not their fault if the hockey rink isn't available until 8pm, or they have to travel 1 hour every Wednesday to the other parent's house, etc.
    Regarding projects, this year I tried something new that appears to be working. It's kind of weird, so please don't hate me immediately ... Students don't have to make a final draft. In fact, they MAY NOT turn in a typed, polished finished product. I want dog-earred copies of notes, scrawled and scribbled outlines, pen mixed with pencil -- whatever they could do in 4 or 5 class periods!
    
    Here's the link to the assignment handout. This is a flashblog, so I don't have time to add lots of details now, but I would be happy to answer follow-up questions in the comments section!

Something boring can be flipping awesome

3/14/2015

 
         I have tried eight or nine different video formats this year, and I still don't have a clear-cut favorite. Sometimes I think the topic helps to determine the most appropriate format.  I also have a personal rule that no video should take more than 2 hours to create (preferably closer to one hour), to prevent myself from going overboard.
         Below you can see two versions about the same topic: George Washington's presidency. I spent the most time preparing the script, distilling those 8 years to the most essential elements, and using a thematic approach rather than a pedantic chronology of events.
         I first recorded the video on the left -- with a school-supplied Macbook in my son's bedroom (because it was the quietest place in the house that afternoon!). This is my second take. Clearly I need a hair stylist but that's not in the budget. I spent about 20 minutes with iMovie to add the text captions and to trim out some bad takes.
         The right-side video was made using Screencast-o-Matic to capture the screen display. What you see is a Word document. I changed the font color for each box to white (starting at the end). Then I clicked the Undo button as I talked through the presentation to show those words. This video was recorded in my car on another afternoon, while waiting for my son at a sports practice. I think the laptop microphone sensitivity was set too high, which explains the crackling audio.
           My students have never seen the video on the left. Instead, I linked the "boring" video on the right. To my surprise, all my teaching assistants and several students told me they appreciated that format. It's clear, easy to follow, free of distractions, and informative enough to tell what they needed to know -- in about 9 minutes.

           And below you can see the corroborating data. If you're really curious you can see the questions here. 68 students (82% of my class) gave satisfactory answers to every question. 6 students needed to re-attempt at least one question, and 8 other students still need to do the same. That's a well above-average success rate. Best of all, the students' preparation led to a terrific set of class conversations about issues like the Whiskey Rebellion, the French Revolution, presidential power, Alexander Hamilton's monetary policy, and other topics that would probably bore my wife to tears....
Picture
          The moral of this story: You really don't need fancy videos to produce strong student learning.

Scientists: This is all just flipping crap

3/8/2015

 
       A recently published study from Brigham Young University is making the rounds on #flipclass. Yeah, I read the whole thing, not just the headlines or the abstract. The basic results report no statistical difference in learning between freshman biology students whose class was flipped vs. a more traditional class by the same professor. The authors conclude that active-learning strategies are more valuable than providing "costly" online instruction.  Yikes. Have I just been wasting my time??
Picture
       Oh, NDT, I can't stay mad at you! And of course you're almost always right, except #thedress is absolutely blue and black.
       But anyway, the study in question was not an astrophysical or climatological observation -- it was a contrived long-term experiment. I know, that's how science works. The authors make a good case in the first pages about the not-very-sciencey aspects of prior research which had no control group and/or included too many variables.  A well-designed experiment is almost as good as a toasted bacon sandwich (high praise!), but I have some reasons to disregard and devalue this BYU study:
  1. The class studied was a college-level course, which meets three times per week. The dynamics of a college course are widely different from what I experience as a day-to-day middle school teacher. Furthermore, the class size was almost 60 students; I teach four groups every day, with between 19 and 24 in each section. Again, that difference produces very different dynamics in the classroom.
  2. A major reason why I started flipping was to enhance connections with parents and with special education staff. My students' support group of adults get quite familiar with what & how I am teaching this week. That is generally not an issue or a need for college students, who are probably not getting academic support from their parents (?!) and no longer have an IEP. The bar graphs of exam results for "nonflipped" and "flipped" appear level in this study, but I believe that if I ran a similar study then the nonflipped score average would be much lower.
  3. The study authors did not analyze or even comment about the length, the quality, and the specific nature of the professor's online videos. Garbage in, garbage out is a common IT saying. Some flipping lessons you find out there in Youtube-land are dull, pedantic, and unwatchable!  If the professor's video lessons were not really comparable with class lectures in educational value, then it's remarkable that the "flipped" group performed as well as they did!  Flipping teachers are still learning details of the best format, filming approach, interactibility, etc. of our online videos. There's more than one way to skin this cat, and this study should have been more specific about the online instruction provided to its experiment subjects.
  4. Note that the formative assessments for the flipped group were performed during class, presumably with supervision to ensure academic honesty. However the chart on page 3 and subsequent descriptions show that the nonflipped group took some assessments outside of class, where they might have been able to check their notes, a website, etc. for helpful information! That would not impact the graph of unit exam performance, but it may certainly skew some of the other data and it could have improved those students' attitude toward the course. (Easy quizzes!)
  5. I am also left to wonder: How did this college professor use the extra 15-20 minutes of class time with the flipped group when he/she wasn't lecturing?!  The real-life difference between the two courses is not described clearly enough for me to understand them. 

So anyway, I will keep doing what I'm doing: teaching the best way I can.  I don't make any cash from flipping. (In fact, I would probably make more if I spent more time tutoring and less time blogging!)  If science can develop an even better way to do what I need to do, then I will jump ship faster than the speed of light ... just to see what Neil DeGrasse Tyson would do about it.

A thought for flipping beginners

3/2/2015

 
Flipping can be weird, scary, confusing, unnerving, and overwhelming.... that's why I'm glad I started small.

         This week I got a reminder of my own beginnings when I dredged up this video from my Youtube channel. It's the time of year for us 8th grade teachers to make high-school course recommendations. At my middle school we have heterogeneous grouping, but in 9th grade there are two levels for World History. It's the first time these students have been officially ability-grouped or tracked for social studies. In February 2013, I got the idea to film a single presentation so I could show it to all 4 of my classes. Then they would all get exactly the same message, I wouldn't be repeating myself all day long, and if a student were absent that day then I could just say "Watch this"!
          I filmed the video with a simple Kodak FlipCam and edited it with iMovie. I sort-of scripted the video ahead of time, which helped greatly. The post-production process took about 3 times longer than I spend now, because I have gained so much practice since then. I'm still pretty pleased with the results, so even though the course names have been changed, I can recycle this video every year to serve the same purpose.
          So if you have considered making the flip, I suggest that you start like I did. Record a video on a topic you don't want to repeat 3 or 4 times in one day. Choose a subject you feel confident speaking about, so when the camera is on then you're less likely to panic and freeze. You can even show the clip during class, to observe the students' reaction. (I did that for this video in 2013, but now I just post it online for them to find and view anytime.)
  
          Comments, questions, advice, wisecrack remarks, etc. are always welcome below!
    Picture

    Who is this flipping guy?!

       Andrew Swan is in year 20  of teaching middle school (currently grade 8 US Civics/Government in a Boston suburb). Previously he taught 6th, 7th, and 8th grade English, US History, geography, and ancient history in Massachusetts and Maine. 
      For the past 6 years, Andrew has flipped nearly all his direct instruction so we have more class time for simulations, deep discussions, analyzing primary sources, etc. ... and also to promote mastery for students at all levels.
      His wonderful wife and his 2 high school-age children indulge Andrew's blogging, tweeting, & other behaviors. These include co-moderating the #sschat Twitter sessions and Facebook page. 
      ​
    Andrew does not always refer to himself in the third-person. 

    Twitter @flipping_A_tchr
    Instagram @swanversations

    Categories

    All
    Action Civics
    Analogies
    Assessment
    Asynchronous
    Bloom's Taxonomy
    Critiques
    Curriculum Planning
    DBQ
    Definitions Of Flipped
    First Days Of School
    #flipblogs
    Flipping Problems
    FlipTech
    For Beginners
    FTEC18
    FTNE19
    Gamified
    Grading
    Historical Thinking
    Homework
    In-class Flipping
    Local History
    Making Videos
    Mastery
    Not Flipping
    Parents
    Projects
    Reflective Blogging
    Research
    SBL
    Schoology
    Snow Days
    Special Ed
    Student Centered
    Student Survey
    #ThisisWhyIFlip
    Troubleshooting
    Writing

    Archives

    October 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly